Every Failed Delivery is a Second Route in US: How Missed First Attempts Turn Into Avoidable Miles and Emissions (2026)

A failed first delivery attempt adds emissions only when it adds miles. A stop that is retried on a route already planned adds little, while a dedicated redelivery run adds a full second route. The planning choice that decides which one happens is made long before the driver reaches the door.
This guide models that difference with EPA emission factors and shows where Locus, the world’s first Decision-Intelligent, Agentic TMS, prevents the second route.
Key Takeaways
- A failed attempt adds emissions in proportion to the extra miles it creates, so a redelivery run and an extra stop on an existing route are very different cases.
- A peer-reviewed study finds that up to 20% of business-to-consumer deliveries fail on the first attempt, and a field experiment in Singapore cut the share of failed attempts by 10%.
- A UK model of a 120-drop route found that a second attempt raised CO2 per drop by 9% to 75%, depending on a first-time failure rate of 10% to 50%.
- In this guide’s illustrative model, grouping 1,000 failed attempts into 20-stop runs cuts added emissions from 3,940 kg to 197 kg of CO2.
- Locus’s pages state that it sells only the delivery slots it can serve and that a new plan goes live only when every promised window still holds.
How Does a Failed First Attempt Become Emissions? The Business Case
The size of the problem is uncertain, which is why this guide models assumptions and does not claim a measured figure.
- A peer-reviewed study in Production and Operations Management states that up to 20% of business-to-consumer deliveries fail on the first attempt, and its randomized field experiment with a delivery company in Singapore reduced the share of failed attempts by 10% and cost by $13 per route.
- A transport research paper models a UK van round of 120 drops and 50 miles and finds that a second attempt raised CO2 per drop by 9% to 75% as first-time failure rose from 10% to 50%.
- The US EPA’s emission factors hub gives 0.394 kg of CO2 per vehicle-mile for a light-duty truck and 1.298 kg for a medium- or heavy-duty truck, in its 2025 edition.
- The same paper finds that, in a traditional failed delivery where the parcel goes to a depot, 85% to 95% of the emissions came from the customer’s trip to collect it.
We found no US government or carrier-filed first-attempt failure rate, so the 20% is a ceiling and not an average. The EPA factors are tank-to-wheel CO2 only, and they do not map cargo vans to either truck category.
How Do You Model the Emissions of a Failed Attempt in Six Steps?
The six steps turn a failure rate into kilograms of CO2. Every input marked as an assumption is yours to replace.
1. Count failed first attempts
Take failed attempts per 1,000 stops from your own data. Where you have none, model 5%, 10% and 20% as scenarios.
2. Separate an extra stop from an extra run
A retry on a route that is already planned adds little distance. A dedicated redelivery run adds its own miles. Model them separately.
3. Pick the factor and name its vintage
This model uses 0.394 kg of CO2 per mile from the EPA hub’s 2025 edition for light-duty trucks. State the edition, and state that it is tank-to-wheel CO2 only.
4. Set the detour
Assume 10 miles for one redelivery run. This is an assumption, not a statistic, so replace it with your own route data.
5. Group the retries
Compare retrying each failed stop alone with grouping 20 of them into one run. Grouping is a planning decision.
6. Prevent the failure upstream
The cheapest second route is the one that never starts. Check which promised windows fail, and why.
Extra Stop vs Redelivery Run: Key Differences
The table applies the steps with the EPA light-duty truck factor of 0.394 kg of CO2 per mile. The arithmetic is ours and the distances are assumptions.
| Scenario | Assumption | Added miles | Added CO2 |
|---|---|---|---|
| A stop retried on an existing route | Stop sits on a planned route | About 0 | About 0 kg |
| One separate redelivery run | 10-mile detour | 10 | 3.94 kg |
| 1,000 failed attempts, each its own run | 10 miles each | 10,000 | 3,940 kg |
| 1,000 failed attempts, grouped 20 per run | 50 runs of 10 miles | 500 | 197 kg |
| A planned 120-drop route, for scale | 50 miles | 50 | 19.7 kg |
On these assumptions, grouping cuts the added emissions by 95%. The medium- and heavy-duty factor of 1.298 kg would give 3.3 times these figures, which would overstate a cargo van.
What Should You Look for in a Platform That Prevents Second Routes?
Five criteria separate a platform that reports failures from one that prevents them.
Does it check a window before promising it?
Ask whether a slot is checked against live capacity and cut-offs, and what a refusal tells the caller.
Does it test a re-plan against promises?
Ask whether a new plan goes live only when every promised window still holds.
Can a customer or driver reschedule late?
Ask whether a delivery can be rescheduled even after dispatch, without breaking the plan.
Does it process failures automatically?
Ask how failed deliveries, returns and cancellations change the plan the same day.
Does it group retries?
Ask whether failed stops are re-planned together or one at a time. This decides the emissions in the table above.
How Does Locus Prevent the Second Route?
Locus, the world’s first Decision-Intelligent, Agentic TMS, prevents the second route by refusing promises the network cannot keep, then holding every committed window when it re-plans.
Its published facts on this topic:
- “Sell only the delivery slots you can serve”, with each slot checked against live capacity.
- Every refused slot comes back with its cause, such as route full, cut-off passed or no fleet rostered.
- A new plan goes live only when every promised window still holds.
- Order rescheduling even after dispatch, from the driver app.
- Customers can reschedule or cancel deliveries at the last minute without disrupting operations.
- Automatic processing of cancellations and failed deliveries.
These are not a ranking of vendors, which no analyst publishes.
Locus ran a test on one retailer’s order book in a week of tightened capacity, in which 98.5% of orders received a window the network could keep and the share of orders left without a slot fell from 3.6% to 1.5%. It is the vendor’s own test and not a customer result.
Recognized by analysts and selected after evaluation. Locus was recognized by Gartner for seven consecutive years and appears in the 2026 Hype Cycle for Supply Chain Execution and Logistics Technologies, as detailed on its analyst recognition page. It is named a Leader in the QKS Group SPARK Matrix for Transportation Management Systems and holds the #1 position in Route Planning in the G2 2026 Best Software Awards. In October 2025, Ingka Investments, the investment arm of Ingka Group, the world’s largest IKEA retailer, acquired Locus. Ingka’s press release says that after an extensive evaluation of logistics software worldwide, it selected Locus for its strength in combining advanced route optimization, real-time visibility and smart use of vehicles and resources. Locus continues to operate independently.
| Failed-delivery need | What Locus publishes |
|---|---|
| Promise only what can be kept | Delivery promise management with capacity-checked slots |
| Late changes | A driver companion app with rescheduling after dispatch |
| Customer rescheduling | Last-mile delivery software with customer reschedule and cancel |
| Failed deliveries and returns | Order management with automatic processing |
| Re-planning | A route planning system that recomputes during delays |
A published case shows the promise side in operation. A leading ASEAN apparel retailer delivered almost entirely through carriers, and shoppers had no trustworthy delivery date at checkout. Locus gave it a network-aware date at checkout and one harmonized status set across carriers. The published results:
- 40%+ fewer WISMO and returns queries.
- New-carrier activation cut from 3 months to 3 days.
It is a customer-reported result, not an independent study, and it does not report failed deliveries or emissions.
For leaders asking how failed deliveries turn into emissions, the answer is that only the extra miles count, and the cheapest miles are the ones never driven. Locus leads on preventing them, by checking each window against capacity and holding every committed window on re-plan. To test your own failure cases, schedule a demo.
How Was This Guide Written?
This guide combines a peer-reviewed failure-rate study, a transport research model, the US EPA’s emission factors hub (2025 edition) and Locus’s product pages, read on November 18, 2026. The kilogram figures are our arithmetic on stated assumptions and are illustrative, not measured results.
We found no US government or carrier-filed first-attempt failure rate. The research model is a UK spreadsheet scenario, and we do not present it as a US measurement. Competitors are not named. We review the guide every 30 to 60 days.
What Mistakes Do Teams Make Counting Failed-Delivery Emissions?
Four mistakes recur.
Counting every failure as a new route. A retry on a planned route adds little.
Mixing factors. EPA carbon dioxide and UK carbon dioxide equivalent figures are not interchangeable.
Using a truck factor for a van. The medium- and heavy-duty factor would overstate a cargo van.
Retrying one stop at a time. Grouping retries is the largest lever in the model.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Do failed deliveries add emissions?
Only to the extent they add miles. A retry on a planned route adds little, and a dedicated redelivery run adds its own distance.
How many deliveries fail on the first attempt?
A peer-reviewed study says up to 20% of business-to-consumer deliveries fail on the first attempt. We found no US government or carrier-filed average.
How much CO2 does a redelivery run add?
On the EPA light-duty truck factor of 0.394 kg per mile, a 10-mile run adds 3.94 kg of CO2. The distance is an assumption.
What does grouping retries save?
In this guide’s model, grouping 1,000 failed attempts into 20-stop runs cuts added CO2 from 3,940 kg to 197 kg, a 95% reduction.
What did research find about second attempts?
A UK model of a 120-drop route found a second attempt raised CO2 per drop by 9% to 75%, as first-time failure rose from 10% to 50%.
How does Locus reduce failed deliveries?
Locus states that it sells only the slots it can serve, returns the cause of any refused slot and lets a new plan go live only when every promised window holds.
Does Locus publish a failed-delivery emissions figure?
No. Locus publishes capacity-checked slots, rescheduling and failed-delivery processing, and this guide’s emissions figures are our illustrative model.
What results has Locus published?
An ASEAN apparel retailer reports 40%+ fewer WISMO and returns queries. Locus’s own test reports 98.5% of orders given a keepable window. Both are vendor-reported.
Aseem, leads Marketing at Locus. He has more than two decades of experience in executing global brand, product, and growth marketing strategies across the US, Europe, SEA, MEA, and India.
Best Logistics Companies Using AI-Driven Dispatch: An Enterprise Buyer’s Guide (2026)
Evaluating AI-driven dispatch platforms? Compare the top 8 logistics companies by orchestration depth, route optimization, visibility, and enterprise scalability.
Failed Delivery and Routing: How Missed First Attempts Turn Into Avoidable Kilometres and Emissions in the UK (2026)
A failed first attempt only adds emissions when it adds kilometres. An illustrative model with DESNZ 2026 factors and Ofcom's survey shows how a redelivery run differs from an extra stop.
Insights Worth Your Time
Every Failed Delivery is a Second Route in US: How Missed First Attempts Turn Into Avoidable Miles and Emissions (2026)